October and November are conference months in the field of teaching and learning. Members of our TLC team have been attending and participating in local events, and so for this month’s blog post, we offer a sampling of what we’ve learned. Ki attended the BC Campus Digital Learning Forum, Heather attended Lessons in Trust: Alternative Assessments in the Era of AI at UBC Vancouver, and Mark attended a BC Campus FLO Friday event. Read about what we each learned here.
Ki’s Learning
Dr. Donna Chowdhury and Dr. Upasana Thakkar from Yorkville University gave a workshop at the BCcampus Digital Learning Forum on November 3rd titled “AI said so. Now what? Teaching students to argue with AI.” They coined a simple “4V Framework” for critical AI literacy that centres student research and critical thinking skills while using AI. The 4Vs ask students to engage with AI output by taking these steps: verify, validate, value, and voice. This approach can be practiced as an in-class exercise, as an audit of AI summaries of course readings, or as steps students take and report on in projects. I’ve adapted their student prompts for use in courses at Emily Carr:
| Action | Guiding Question | What Students Do |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Verify (check the claims) | What specific claims or outputs is the AI making, and can each one be checked? | Break the output into individual claims. Check each against the original text, image, data or a credible source. Mark anything they can’t check as unconfirmed, not false. |
| 2. Validate (weigh the sources) | Where did this come from, and how reliable is that origin? | Identify what the AI likely drew on. Weigh credibility and bias. Notice when the AI can’t say where an idea came from at all. |
| 3. Value (judge the relevance) | Even if it’s accurate, does it serve the task? | Assess if it fits with the assignment. Weigh strengths against limitations. Decide what to keep, what to cut, and what’s missing. |
| 4. Voice (hold your perspective) | What do I actually think, and can I say it in my own words or with my own creative practice? | Spot where the AI’s interpretation replaced their own thinking or making. Rebuild the argument or image in their own voice and style. Treat AI as a starting point, not a conclusion. |
Heather’s Learning
I attended the conference, Lessons in Trust: Alternative Assessments in the Era of AI, hosted at UBC Vancouver, Oct. 23-24. The theme of the conference was how to shift attention away from grades and toward learning – as keynote speaker Asao Inoue put it “grades are often mistaken for evidence of learning or lack of learning, when in fact they are not necessarily either.” Almost all presenters, mostly faculty from UBC, SFU, and other local institutions, teach curriculum that requires conventional final grades, so it was interesting to hear how they navigate alternative grading practices within institutional constraints.
The most common alternative approaches include incorporating self-assessment into assignments – either alongside instructor assessment, or in lieu of. For example, one instructor who was tired of trying to distinguish between a 72% and a 74% reported on her experiments with “bucket grading” where the instructor (and later students) metaphorically assess work using colour-coded buckets which loosely align with grades (e.g., a purple bucket might correspond to A-level work). A student’s “graded” work might show a rainbow of colours in different sections that indicate which parts need more work. Apparently, students perceive this feedback to be more playful and empowering, but learning to assess their own work via buckets also helps them understand the learning outcomes.
The big takeaway for me is that you don’t need to be teaching a pass/fail course to try alternative assessment: even a traditionally graded class can incorporate pass/fail components or self-assessments (even many of them) that take the weight off instructor grading. Not only do these approaches often improve student learning but they also improve classroom community and relationships: by reducing the friction points around grades and ranking, students report better relationships with both instructors and peers. And instructors report that removing some pressure from evaluation frees them to appreciate and even enjoy the work students create.
In this era of machine learning, how can we design assessment to centre the human in our relationships with students? Alternative approaches to grading offer one path to explore. You can learn more about ungrading here.
Mark’s Learning
I attended one of BC Campus’s “FLO Friday” events on Oct. 23. FLO stands for Facilitating Learning Online, and this month’s event was focused on Sustaining Student Engagement Online. Presenter Mariela Krüger de Azevedo presented several ideas for how to maintain student engagement even in asynchronous online classes. First and most central was to prioritize classroom community: students are far more likely to disengage when they feel disconnected from their peers or instructor. For this reason, use of AI and other technology tools will never fully replace the value of instructor presence – online students value human-to-human connection just as much as their in-person peers do. For more ideas about building engaging online courses, visit the TLC website.